
TO CHEESE OR NOT TO CHEESE?
That...isn't even a question.
(Clearly Hamlet never had a triple cream.)


Pick up a new loyalty card at the cheese counter!
(What do you have to lose, except maybe your skinny jeans?)
new swag alert.
Proud to have grown in to the area's biggest cheese shop.
Offering a vast local & imported selection of divine cheeses!
Have questions? Need recommendations? Want to curate a cheese board to your taste?
Our monger LOVES to talk cheese- send her a note at and follow @whatsthecurd on instagram.
We want all your cheese dreams to come true.
Stock changes quickly, if we are out of something you order, we will let you know and suggest a fabulous replacement.
LOCAL
*super local within 20 miles, otherwise NY state
Adiron-Jack, Nettle Meadow Farm, NY, Cow - NEW
Alderney, Cowbella + Dan Finn*
Briar Summit, Nettle Meadow Farm, NY, Cow, Goat, Sheep
Camembert, Chaseholm Farm
Nimbus, Chaseholm Farm
Kunik, Nettle Meadow Farm, NY
St. Stephen, Four Fat Fowl, NY
Hard Cider Washed Gouda, Bye Brook Farm, NY* - OUT OF STOCK
Tumbleweed Cave Aged, 5 Spokes Creamery, NY
Redmond, 5 Spokes Creamery, NY - OUT OF STOCK
Welsh Cheddar, 5 Spokes Creamery - OUT OF STOCK
Harvest Moon, 5 Spokes Creamery, NY
Jersey Girl, Cooperstown Cheese Company, NY
BLUES
Bayley Hazen Blue, Jasper Hill Farm, VT, Cow
Ewe's Blue, Old Chatham Sheepherding Company, NY, Cow
Great Hill Blue, Great Hill Farm, MA, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
Gorgonzola Cremificato, Italy, Cow
Rogue River Blue, Rogue River Creamery, Oregon, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
Stilton, England, Cow
WASHED RIND
Epoisses, France, Cow
Taleggio, Italy, Cow
Willoughby, Jasper Hill Farm, VT, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
TRIPLE CREAMS
Brillat Savarin, France, *(mongers top five fave!)
Briar Summit, Nettle Meadow Farm, NY, Cow, Goat, Sheep - NEW
Champlain Valley Organic Triple Cream - OUT OF STOCK
Cremeux de Borgogne, France
Murray's Delice, France
Fromager D'Affinois, France
Kunik, Nettle Meadow Farm, NY
La Tur, France - OUT OF STOCK
Nimbus, Chaseholm Farm, NY
St. Stephen, Four Fat Fowl, NY
SEMI-SOFT/TOMMES/SWISS STYLE//NUTTY
Alderney, Cowbella + Dan Finn, Cow
Drunken Goat, Spain, Cow
Etivaz, Switzerland, Cow
Gruyere, Switzerland, Cow
Jersey Girl, Cooperstown Cheese Company, NY, Cow
Ossau Iraty, France, Sheep - OUT OF STOCK
Pecorino Foglie de Noce (wrapped in walnut leaves), Italy, Sheep - OUT OF STOCK
Pyrenees Brebis, France, Sheep - NEW
Tomme de Savoie, France, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
BLOOMY/BRIE/BRIE-LIKE
Briar Summit, Nettle Meadow Farm, NY, Cow, Goat, Sheep - NEW
Camembert, Chaseholm Farm, NY, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
Coupole, Vermont Creamery, VT, Goat
Humboldt Fog, Cypress Grove Creamery, CA, Goat
Murray's Mini Brie, France, Cow - NEW
Robiola Bosina, Italy, Cow & Sheep - OUT OF STOCK
Truffle Tremor, Cypress Grove Creamery, CA, Goat
Sainte-Maure, France, Goat
MANCHEGO
Manchego, 12 months, Spain, Sheep
UNIQUE & MISCELLANEOUS
Casatica di Bufala, (Buffalo Milk!) Italy
Briar Summit, Nettle Meadow Farm, NY, Cow, Goat, Sheep
Coupole, Vermont Creamery, VT, Goat
Harvest Moon, 5 Spokes Creamery, NY, (mimolette style)
DELI SLICED (order by the pound)
Aged provolone - OUT OF STOCK
Emmentaler (swiss)
CHEVRES
Bucheron, Montchevre, Wisconsin, Goat - OUT OF STOCK
Chèvre, Painted Goat, NY, Goat - OUT OF STOCK
Chèvre, Nettle Meadow Farm, NY - OUT OF STOCK
Up In Smoke, Rivers Edge, Oregon - OUT OF STOCK (seasonal)
FETAS, MOZZARELLAS, CURDS, PARM
Burrata, Lioni, Cow
Cheddar Curds, Plain, Cow
Feta, Lively Run Goat Dairy, NY, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
Mozzarella, Fresh, 1lb, Cow
Mozzarella, Smoked, Fresh, Cow 1lb
Parmigiano Reggiano, Italy, Cow
Pecorino, Italy, Cow
Ricotta, Lioni, Cow
GOUDAS
Aged Goat Gouda, 1 year, Holland, Goat
Young Gouda, Smoked, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
Beemster, Holland, Aged approx 18 months, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
Ewephoria, Holland, Sheep
Hard Cider Washed, Bye Brook Farm, NY, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
Jakes Aged Gouda, Cow
Jakes Smoked Gouda, Cow
Two Sisters Isabella Gouda, Holland, Cow
CHEDDARS
Grafton 2 Year Aged Cheddar, VT, Cow
Jake's Aged Cheddar, NY, Cow
Mrs. Quickes Cheddar, England, Cow
Tumbleweed Cheddar Cave Aged, 5 Spokes Creamery, NY, Cow
Redmond, 5 Spokes Creamery, NY, Cow - OUT OF STOCK
Red Dragon Mustard Seed & Ale Cheddar, UK, Cow
Sage Derby English Cheddar - OUT OF STOCK
Welsh Cheddar, 5 Spokes Creamery - OUT OF STOCK